---
title: "Sixth Circuit keeps Kentucky opioid case against PBMs in federal court"
publication: The Precedent
section: "PBM Rebates"
date: 2026-09-25
url: https://theprecedent.org/article/sixth-circuit-keeps-kentucky-opioid-case-against-pbms-in-federal-court
---

# Sixth Circuit keeps Kentucky opioid case against PBMs in federal court

*The Sixth Circuit reversed an order returning Kentucky's opioid lawsuit against Express Scripts and OptumRx to state court. The ruling addressed jurisdiction, without deciding liability.*

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled on September 18, 2026, in Commonwealth of Kentucky ex rel. Russell Coleman v. Express Scripts, Inc., et al., No. 25-5866. It reversed a remand order in an opioid lawsuit against Express Scripts entities and OptumRx.

Kentucky alleged the PBMs exchanged preferred opioid formulary placement for manufacturer rebates and fees, violating state consumer-protection law and creating a public nuisance. It sought civil penalties, injunctive relief and abatement; the appellate ruling awarded no damages.

The companies invoked federal-officer removal under 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a)(1), citing their work administering federal prescription benefits. Kentucky argued its disclaimer of claims involving federally directed conduct required state-court proceedings.

The court allowed federal jurisdiction and returned the case for further proceedings in the Eastern District of Kentucky, No. 5:24-cv-00303. It found colorable federal defenses sufficient for removal, without deciding those defenses on their merits. The opinion records no admission of liability.

---
Cite as: The Precedent. "Sixth Circuit keeps Kentucky opioid case against PBMs in federal court." September 25, 2026. https://theprecedent.org/article/sixth-circuit-keeps-kentucky-opioid-case-against-pbms-in-federal-court
